Detective Lindy D’Arnaud and her partner Boggs investigates the murder of a young entrepreneur, Ethan Moll, and everyone in town is pointing fingers at his New Age, neo-hippie, miracle-manifesting, smokeshow of an ex-girlfriend, Gabby – particularly the victim’s best friend Jenna. Was it a case of jealousy turning violent, or was the victim involved in business dealings that put him in danger?

While this is happening, Lindy is also competing for the affection of her wife, when April’s former boyfriend and sperm donor to their baby decides to move back to town, leaving Lindy with concerns about what it means when her child’s biological daddy enters the picture full-time. Can they be postmodern in Western Kentucky where living as a queer person is a daily tenuous situation?